Witch 4.4.3 is out with one fix: It no longer ignores tabs in Safari that have never been active.
We weren’t ignoring them on purpose, and in the past, we didn’t ignore them. However, a recent change in Safari’s Accessibility information for those tabs rendered them invisible to Witch. We’ve now forced those invisible tabs back to the visible realm.
Thanks to a couple of different users for reporting the issue.
Update via Witch’s in-app updater, or download a fresh copy from the Witch web page (you won’t lose your settings).
Thank you for the fix!